Carlos Donizete Froes

Applying for	Debian Developer, uploading
Applicant	Carlos Donizete Froes <coringao@riseup.net>, currently Debian Contributor
OpenPGP fingerprint	2157 630B D441 A775 BEFF D35F FA63 ADA6 B638 B780
Activity timespan	2019-01-20 to 2019-01-29
Status	Closed
Completed	2019-01-29
Advocates	none yet
Debian account name	coringao
Missing requirements	Advocate Application Manager report
Requirements OK	Declaration of intent SC/DFSG/DMUP agreement Key consistency checks

Requirements

Requirement	Approved by	Approved date	Notes
578: Declaration of intent	nm@debian.org	2019-01-20
578: SC/DFSG/DMUP agreement	nm@debian.org	2019-01-20
578: Advocate	-	-
578: Key consistency checks	mattia	2019-01-20
578: Application Manager report	-	-

(download all signed statements in a single mailbox file)

Log

Date	Author	Requirement	Action	Content	Public
2019-01-20 01:11	coringao	-	-	Process created	yes
2019-01-20 02:41	coringao	Declaration of intent	add_statement	Added a new statement	yes
2019-01-20 02:41	nm@debian.org	Declaration of intent	req_approve	New statement received, the requirement seems satisfied	yes
2019-01-20 03:08	coringao	SC/DFSG/DMUP agreement	add_statement	Added a new statement	yes
2019-01-20 03:08	nm@debian.org	SC/DFSG/DMUP agreement	req_approve	New statement received, the requirement seems satisfied	yes
2019-01-20 14:41	mattia	Key consistency checks	req_approve	Requirement approved	yes
2019-01-26 09:38	tobi	-	-	Sorry to be the bad guy here, but I had interactions with coringao on some occasions and I think he is _not_ ready for DD, at least not now: On mayor problematic pattern I see is that he makes some error, he is told about it but he still do the same errors later. - I think there are problems regarding his understanding how open source works - for example I observed that he more than often forks upstream to put his name in it, but when diffing the upstream and his code you see that there are only minor changes, mostly in spelling errors... (e.g cavestory-nx #906536 , blastem #919540) - (blastem was the trigger for this message to nm, but I saw the same thing already earler e.g in #870215#25) - I have the feeling he does not take copyright serious. #906536 is one example, but he has been told already earlier. - I have also the feeling that he ignores other peoples input. For example, he has been told not to open new RFS bugs but to re-use the olds one for stuff that has not been sponsored, but he ignored that (e.g cavestory-nx, pokemmo-installer #886606 ). Another example is for non-free game installers, e.g stendhal-installer and pokemmo-installer: In stendhal he was asked to not name it stendhal but stendhal-installer (#870215) and in pokemmo he did not learn from that and did only so after a FTP-Master rejection. (#884740) Sorry for being the game spoiler...	yes
2019-01-29 15:22	coringao	-	proc_close	I am canceling my Debian Developer process because I am not ready at the moment to join the group. Thanks!	yes